Hockey Fan Forums banner

Are the Pittsburgh Penguins cheaters?

19K views 54 replies 24 participants last post by  Flyers  
Wow O_O This fight is pretty stupid ... First off I'm gonna put it into perspective. If the NHL wanted to save a franchise they would of pput Crosby on the Coyotes or Florida two teams that aren't doing the best. If they were looking for money they would put him in NYR. The acusations that they "tanked" to get a top draft pick are right but who gives a dam. It's a strategy to rebuilding. What are you gonna do? Call them immoral ? Like they give a flying f*** the penguins are winning games and bringing in fans. In 20 years who knows what will happen to this franchise but i don't think they will be out of business like someone else so rudely said. They are a NHL team and they just have 2 superstars like what do you want ? You could call out the caps for cheating when Ovie was available like jeez
At the time, Pittsburgh was in danger of moving, which put them in worse shape than Coyotes or Florida. If it weren't for Crosby/Malkin and the team starting to win, the team would possibly be elsewhere, and Lemieux would definitely not be the owner.

The problem that people have isn't that they tanked, it's that they tanked at the right time twice, drafting three generational players (Lemieux, Crosby, Malkin) and another elite forward (Jagr), who could even be argued as a generational talent in his own right. Had their teams been as bad in those years, then I'm sure that they would be happy to have all those players themselves. It's mostly jealousy that they were bad at the right times.

The thing I don't like is how people claim the Penguins are the model franchise for a rebuilding team. How many times are there going to be three generational talents within two years that a rebuilding team can pick? You can give as many 1st overall picks to Florida or Phoenix, the odds of them drafting a player the quality of Crosby or Malkin is ridiculously low.

If anything, Boston should be the model franchise for a rebuilding team, smart drafting, smart signings, good trades while keeping the pipeline active. Something that every franchise should at least have a shot at doing.
 
Fair enough, but teams that are stinking it up can't really follow Detroit's plan right now, they're obviously what every team should be striving for. Boston went from having a top five draft pick three years ago to where they are now.

Detroit's the model franchise overall. And Boston's the model franchise in terms of an actual rebuild.

Pittsburgh's the model franchise if you get two generational talents. ;)