There is no talk of upside in this discussion. This is about the Leafs making the playoffs this season.LMAO YA I don't understand math at all. Stupid me I've only won awards for it.
Price v. Toskala - Easily Price
There were a group of 4 goalies. I said all were as good or better. Smith I would say is as good. LeClair and Price I say are better. I would have no problem swapping Halak for Toskala in net because I think he is just about as good. Neither has shown they have what it takes to be a #1 in the NHL. Skill wise there is little difference but Halak's upside dwarfs what potential Toskala brings to the table.
It is unfair to say that anyone other than perhaps Price is as good or better, because due to inconsistency there is a third option. Worse.
None of those teams have an advantage in goal going into this season. Anyone your award winning logic seems to be broken.