NHL ASG news thread
Shawn P. Roarke | NHL.com Senior Writer
Jan 18, 2007, 11:30 AM EST
This week, Crashing the Net captures the All-Star spirit. With the All-Star Game set for Jan. 24 in Dallas, CTN takes All-Star angles with many of its features. In the Opening Faceoff, CTN picks a team it believes would be capable of beating either the Eastern or Western Conference All-Stars. The Breakaway, as usual, is observations from around the world of hockey, including some All-Star notes. Working the Boards chats with St. Louis Blue Lee Stempniak, who was named this week to the Western Conference roster for Wednesday’s YoungStars Game. Finally, the Penalty Box answers comments from the readers, including seven All-Star-themed rants.
As always CTN hopes you enjoy this offering and urges you to drop us a line with your thoughts, complaints and suggestions. CTN can be reached at [email protected]. Also note that because the All-Star Game falls on a Thursday, CTN’s usual publication date, this feature will take a one-week sabbatical before returning on Feb. 1.
***
Opening Faceoff
Unlike many people, Crashing the Net has little complaint about the rosters selected for this year’s All-Star Game festivities.
CTN understands that there are limited spots available to slot in the cream of the NHL crop and that political and emotional components work heavily into the selection process. Sure, there are great players left off the rosters for a variety of reasons -- injuries and team representation playing the most key roles in the process.
But, in hearing all the complaints -- both logical and illogical -- from hockey fans about the selection process, as well as the many arguments espoused in support of the unsuccessful “Vote for Rory” campaign, CTN got to thinking about the fact that there are many great players who were not even considered for this year’s All-Star stage for a variety of reasons.
Then, in the way CTN’s convoluted mind sometimes work, the idea of forming a team of unselected players that could compete against either the Eastern Conference or Western Conference All-Stars took hold.
In my scenario, this team – the egotistically named CTN All-Stars – would challenge the winner of next Wednesday’s 2007 NHL All-Star Game to a challenge match, much in the way that local club team from Mystery, Alaska challenged the New York Rangers in the mostly forgettable movie Mystery, Alaska.
It is not per se the traditional All-Snub team, as there are many other players deserving of that honor. Rather, it is a legitimate dream team that CTN believes would be capable of winning any game against any opponent, including the All-Star Game victors.
CTN would serve as the GM of said team, assembling the talent, picking the coaching staff and handling the innumerable intricacies of this hypothetical challenge if it were to take place. Sadly, it will only happen in CTN’s head, and perhaps in a computer simulation.
CTN pictures the challenge, if accepted, taking place Thursday night, the day after the real All-Star Game, at Texas Stadium, home of the Dallas Cowboys in nearby Irving. After all, everything has to be big in Texas, so why not an outdoor game with room for more than 70,000 fans. This would channel the spirit of the hugely successful Heritage Classic in Edmonton a few years back.
All of the gate proceeds would go toward the prize pool in a winner-take-all format to add some spice and legitimacy to the game. To further boost attendance, CTN would do its best to bring the surviving members of Texas-based Pantera back together to play the national anthem, provide between-period entertainment and, maybe, a post-game reunion concert.
But enough of the outside trappings, the game would be the unquestioned star here. And, the CTN team means business.
CTN would secure Jacques Lemaire of the Minnesota Wild as the coach. The man knows how to win, and just as importantly, he knows how to play the two-way game necessary to neutralize and eventually better the collection of stars he will have to face. Peter Laviolette of Carolina and Craig MacTavish of Edmonton would be the assistant coaches as a reward for last year’s successes.
Then, CTN would assemble a traditional 20-man roster to play a complete game, maintaining the necessary balance between the skill players fans want to see strut their stuff and the role players that all winning teams count on.
Members of the CTN team would be pulled from the pool remaining after players from the All-Star and YoungStar games are removed. Presently injured or unavailable players would also be exempt from being selected.
Here, without further ado, is how CTN would populate the team to win the First Annual CTN Challenge Cup.
Goalies
Dominik Hasek (Detroit) and Chris Mason (Nashville). CTN would like to see Mason start the game because he was among the League’s best before Tomas Vokoun recently returned from injury. He would be hungry to shine on such an international stage. If, however, he falters who would you rather have to tap on the shoulder in a relief role? Hasek, who would start stretching about an hour before the game, would be the man to hold the fort as the CTN stars clawed their way back into the game.
Defense
CTN believes in balance in his defensive pairs. There’s nothing wrong with a run-and-gun defender, as long as there is a stay-at-home guy to cover for him when said offensive-minded D man pinches. With the collection of offensive talent on the opposition’s blue line, that becomes even more important as the winning All-Star team will often be throwing a fourth or fifth man into the attack during transition.
As a result, CTN has tried to strike a delicate balance between defenders adept at moving the puck in transition and quarterbacking the attack in the offensive zone with defensemen who understand their primary job is to stay back and blunt forays into our attacking zone.
Tampa Bay’s Dan Boyle and Detroit’s Mathieu Schneider would be out first two puck-moving options. Each would see considerable time on the power play. Montreal’s Andrei Markov would also serve this purpose, although he can play a solid two-way game. Calgary’s Robyn Regehr and Carolina’s Mike Commodore would provide the defensive conscience of this team, each drawing on recent big-game experience to handle the other team’s cavalcade of stars. Ottawa’s Anton Volchenkov would be the sixth defenseman, used as an intimidating presence. He has 125 hits and 154 blocked shots, just the combination CTN craves.
Here is how they would be paired:
Schneider-Regehr
Boyle-Commodore
Markov-Volchenkov
Forwards
CTN avoided the easy route of picking the best 12 non All-Star forwards, regardless of position. Instead, CTN tried to put players in their proper positions and in roles they are used to playing.
Because this is a Jacques Lemaire-coached team and CTN, as the GM, similarly subscribes to a defense-first philosophy, the team will have a pure checking line to counter our opponent’s most dangerous forward unit. While there is a plethora of great checkers available – after all, these players are not usually rewarded with All-Star appearances – CTN felt that a ready-built unit with built-in chemistry would be best suited for the task. Therefore, CTN would select the Devils' checking line of John Madden, Jay Pandolfo and Sergei Brylin, simply the best in the business.
But, CTN is not so naïve as to not understand that we will not win this game 1-0. In fact, CTN believes an all-Russian unit will carry the offensive load with Detroit’s Pavel Datsyuk centering Atlanta’s Ilya Kovalchuk and Buffalo’s Maxim Afinogenov. This trio has combined to score 56 goals and 136 points so far this season.
The second scoring line would feature the vastly underrated Andy McDonald (33 assists) feeding pucks to former Anaheim teammate Paul Kariya, now with Nashville, and Ottawa’s Daniel Alfredsson. That unit can claim 43 goals and 142 points.
FULL STORY

Shawn P. Roarke | NHL.com Senior Writer
Jan 18, 2007, 11:30 AM EST
This week, Crashing the Net captures the All-Star spirit. With the All-Star Game set for Jan. 24 in Dallas, CTN takes All-Star angles with many of its features. In the Opening Faceoff, CTN picks a team it believes would be capable of beating either the Eastern or Western Conference All-Stars. The Breakaway, as usual, is observations from around the world of hockey, including some All-Star notes. Working the Boards chats with St. Louis Blue Lee Stempniak, who was named this week to the Western Conference roster for Wednesday’s YoungStars Game. Finally, the Penalty Box answers comments from the readers, including seven All-Star-themed rants.
As always CTN hopes you enjoy this offering and urges you to drop us a line with your thoughts, complaints and suggestions. CTN can be reached at [email protected]. Also note that because the All-Star Game falls on a Thursday, CTN’s usual publication date, this feature will take a one-week sabbatical before returning on Feb. 1.
***
Opening Faceoff
Unlike many people, Crashing the Net has little complaint about the rosters selected for this year’s All-Star Game festivities.
CTN understands that there are limited spots available to slot in the cream of the NHL crop and that political and emotional components work heavily into the selection process. Sure, there are great players left off the rosters for a variety of reasons -- injuries and team representation playing the most key roles in the process.
But, in hearing all the complaints -- both logical and illogical -- from hockey fans about the selection process, as well as the many arguments espoused in support of the unsuccessful “Vote for Rory” campaign, CTN got to thinking about the fact that there are many great players who were not even considered for this year’s All-Star stage for a variety of reasons.
Then, in the way CTN’s convoluted mind sometimes work, the idea of forming a team of unselected players that could compete against either the Eastern Conference or Western Conference All-Stars took hold.
In my scenario, this team – the egotistically named CTN All-Stars – would challenge the winner of next Wednesday’s 2007 NHL All-Star Game to a challenge match, much in the way that local club team from Mystery, Alaska challenged the New York Rangers in the mostly forgettable movie Mystery, Alaska.
It is not per se the traditional All-Snub team, as there are many other players deserving of that honor. Rather, it is a legitimate dream team that CTN believes would be capable of winning any game against any opponent, including the All-Star Game victors.
CTN would serve as the GM of said team, assembling the talent, picking the coaching staff and handling the innumerable intricacies of this hypothetical challenge if it were to take place. Sadly, it will only happen in CTN’s head, and perhaps in a computer simulation.
CTN pictures the challenge, if accepted, taking place Thursday night, the day after the real All-Star Game, at Texas Stadium, home of the Dallas Cowboys in nearby Irving. After all, everything has to be big in Texas, so why not an outdoor game with room for more than 70,000 fans. This would channel the spirit of the hugely successful Heritage Classic in Edmonton a few years back.
All of the gate proceeds would go toward the prize pool in a winner-take-all format to add some spice and legitimacy to the game. To further boost attendance, CTN would do its best to bring the surviving members of Texas-based Pantera back together to play the national anthem, provide between-period entertainment and, maybe, a post-game reunion concert.
But enough of the outside trappings, the game would be the unquestioned star here. And, the CTN team means business.
CTN would secure Jacques Lemaire of the Minnesota Wild as the coach. The man knows how to win, and just as importantly, he knows how to play the two-way game necessary to neutralize and eventually better the collection of stars he will have to face. Peter Laviolette of Carolina and Craig MacTavish of Edmonton would be the assistant coaches as a reward for last year’s successes.
Then, CTN would assemble a traditional 20-man roster to play a complete game, maintaining the necessary balance between the skill players fans want to see strut their stuff and the role players that all winning teams count on.
Members of the CTN team would be pulled from the pool remaining after players from the All-Star and YoungStar games are removed. Presently injured or unavailable players would also be exempt from being selected.
Here, without further ado, is how CTN would populate the team to win the First Annual CTN Challenge Cup.
Goalies
Dominik Hasek (Detroit) and Chris Mason (Nashville). CTN would like to see Mason start the game because he was among the League’s best before Tomas Vokoun recently returned from injury. He would be hungry to shine on such an international stage. If, however, he falters who would you rather have to tap on the shoulder in a relief role? Hasek, who would start stretching about an hour before the game, would be the man to hold the fort as the CTN stars clawed their way back into the game.
Defense
CTN believes in balance in his defensive pairs. There’s nothing wrong with a run-and-gun defender, as long as there is a stay-at-home guy to cover for him when said offensive-minded D man pinches. With the collection of offensive talent on the opposition’s blue line, that becomes even more important as the winning All-Star team will often be throwing a fourth or fifth man into the attack during transition.
As a result, CTN has tried to strike a delicate balance between defenders adept at moving the puck in transition and quarterbacking the attack in the offensive zone with defensemen who understand their primary job is to stay back and blunt forays into our attacking zone.
Tampa Bay’s Dan Boyle and Detroit’s Mathieu Schneider would be out first two puck-moving options. Each would see considerable time on the power play. Montreal’s Andrei Markov would also serve this purpose, although he can play a solid two-way game. Calgary’s Robyn Regehr and Carolina’s Mike Commodore would provide the defensive conscience of this team, each drawing on recent big-game experience to handle the other team’s cavalcade of stars. Ottawa’s Anton Volchenkov would be the sixth defenseman, used as an intimidating presence. He has 125 hits and 154 blocked shots, just the combination CTN craves.
Here is how they would be paired:
Schneider-Regehr
Boyle-Commodore
Markov-Volchenkov
Forwards
CTN avoided the easy route of picking the best 12 non All-Star forwards, regardless of position. Instead, CTN tried to put players in their proper positions and in roles they are used to playing.
Because this is a Jacques Lemaire-coached team and CTN, as the GM, similarly subscribes to a defense-first philosophy, the team will have a pure checking line to counter our opponent’s most dangerous forward unit. While there is a plethora of great checkers available – after all, these players are not usually rewarded with All-Star appearances – CTN felt that a ready-built unit with built-in chemistry would be best suited for the task. Therefore, CTN would select the Devils' checking line of John Madden, Jay Pandolfo and Sergei Brylin, simply the best in the business.
But, CTN is not so naïve as to not understand that we will not win this game 1-0. In fact, CTN believes an all-Russian unit will carry the offensive load with Detroit’s Pavel Datsyuk centering Atlanta’s Ilya Kovalchuk and Buffalo’s Maxim Afinogenov. This trio has combined to score 56 goals and 136 points so far this season.
The second scoring line would feature the vastly underrated Andy McDonald (33 assists) feeding pucks to former Anaheim teammate Paul Kariya, now with Nashville, and Ottawa’s Daniel Alfredsson. That unit can claim 43 goals and 142 points.
FULL STORY