mclarenf1

This is a trade between 1st (me) and 2nd (him)

MY
vincent lecavalier
nicklaus lidstrom
kristian huselius
tomas holmstrom

for

HIS
dany heatley
daniel briere
tomas kaberle
slava kozlov

may you guys give me some reasons why i should take this trade and some reasons why i shouldn't?

this is MY roster
C Scott Gomez
C Patrick Marleau
LW Rick Nash
LW Tomas Holmstrom
RW Ales Hemsky
RW Kristian Huselius
D Nicklas Lidstrom
D Sergei Zubov
D Philippe Boucher
D Sami Salo
Util Vincent Lecavalier
Util Brad Richards
BN Brian Gionta
BN Alexander Frolov
IR John-Michael Liles
G Roberto Luongo
G Tomas Vokoun
G Manny Fernandez
G Nicklaus Backstrom

HIS roster
C Daniel Briere
C Sidney Crosby
LW Martin Straka
LW Ray Whitney
RW Justin Williams
RW Dany Heatley
D Tomas Kaberle
D Andrej Meszaros
D Robyn Regehr
D Filip Kuba
Util Slava Kozlov
Util Anze Kopitar
BN Jordan Staal
BN Patrice Bergeron

I have also been offered from another person
MY
G Manny Fernandez
G Nicklaus Backstrom

for

HIS
D Scott Neidermeyer

so although i lose lidstrom i will get neidermeyer in return. what do u guys think overall?